The Social Identity and Social Networks of Ethnic Minority Groups in Organizations: A Crucial Test of Distinctiveness Theory Distinctiveness theory posits that patterns of social identity and friendship are based on numeric rarity
نویسندگان
چکیده
* We thank Bernie Milano and Tara Perino for their unflagging support and encouragement; and we are grateful to the student members of the PhD Project for their participation. Thanks also to and two anonymous reviewers of this journal for their constructive criticism and advice. Earlier versions of this paper were presented to helpful audiences at the Audencia Ecole de Management, the Distinctiveness theory posits that patterns of social identity and friendship are based on numeric rarity within specific contexts. In ethnically diverse organizations, the theory predicts that members of the smaller ethnic group (relative to members of the larger ethnic group) will: (a) tend to identify and form friendships within their own ethnic group; and (b) lack access to well-connected individuals in the network of friendship relations. Prior tests have supported these predictions, but they have been unable to rule out the possibility that it was chronic differences in social status and numeric representation in society at large (rather than numeric distinctiveness within specific contexts) that explained the observed patterns of social identity and friendship. In this field-based study, we examined an organization whose social composition effectively controlled for these confounds. We found that members of the smaller ethnic group tended to identify and form friendships within group, as predicted by distinctiveness theory. However, in contrast to previous work, we found that members of the smaller ethnic group were equally well-connected to the center of the friendship network as were the members of the larger ethnic group. The study of informal relations between members of different ethnic groups has been the focus of sustained sociological analysis in the United States for decades (e.g., Park, 1939/1950). The topic has received less attention in organizational studies, but this state of affairs appears to be changing rapidly (for a review, see Proudford & Nkomo, 2006). A key reason that the study of ethnic relations is moving from the margins to a more central place in organizational scholarship is that the workforce has become markedly more diverse, and this has fuelled vigorous interest in the consequences of ethnic diversity in organizational settings. Given the importance of informal social interactions in organizational life (e. question that deserves greater attention from organizational researchers is: How does ethnic diversity within an organization influence informal relations among its members? Perhaps the most influential theoretical approach to this question draws on the " homophily " principle (Lazarsfeld & …
منابع مشابه
Social Dimensions of Consumer Distinctiveness: The Influence of Social Status on Group Identity and Advertising Persuasion
Consumer research using Distinctiveness theory implies that targeted advertisements will be most effective in contexts where the targeted group is a numeric minority. This paper investigates the influence of social status in addition to numeric status. Results demonstrate that incorporating social dimensions increases the explanatory value of distinctiveness theory for consumer research. We dis...
متن کاملIdentity Integration of Afghan Immigrants in Iran: A Grounded Theory Study
Introduction: Iran has hosted foreign immigrants, mostly Afghans and Iraqis, for the past four decades. The number of Afghan refugees registered by the UN Refugee Agency in 2021, shows that among different countries, Iran is the second destination of Afghan refugees after Pakistan. One of the key aspects of immigrants' lives that changes in the context of life and residence in the host communit...
متن کاملSociological Analysis of the Relationship between Ethnic Identity and Civic Participation in the City of Ilam
The present research with a sociological approach studies the relationship between ethnic identity and civic engagement in the city of Ilam. The research methodology is survey and data collection tool is questionnaire. The statistical population includes all male and female people higher than 15 years old in the city of Ilam based on census in 2006. According to Cochran sampling, 400 people wer...
متن کاملIdentity Integration of Afghan Immigrants in Iran: A Grounded Theory Study
Introduction: Iran has hosted foreign immigrants, mostly Afghans and Iraqis, for the past four decades. The number of Afghan refugees registered by the UN Refugee Agency in 2021, shows that among different countries, Iran is the second destination of Afghan refugees after Pakistan. One of the key aspects of immigrants' lives that changes in the context of life and residence in the host communit...
متن کاملComparison of Ethnic and Religious Identity based on Socio-Cultural Variables among the Middle School Students in District 17 of Tehran
Social identity is a constant and permanent process that changes social situations based on individual experiences in these situations. Religious and ethnic identities are two dimensions of social identity that are of great importance in Iranian society. Due to the ethnic diversity in Iran and the proximity of ethnic cultures through migration, ethnic identity is noticeable. Religious identity ...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2007